The battle for the best value for money running shoe: New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9

The battle for the best value for money running shoe: New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9
Gorka Cabañas
Gorka Cabañas
Journalist and RUNNEA content director
Posted on 07-10-2024

We have got into a price spiral where it seems that to fit a good running shoes we have to empty our wallet. So we have set ourselves a clear goal with this article, to find 2 models that offer much more than what their price suggests. And in that quest for quality without compromising the pocket, we're going to pit two contenders that promise to be more than they appear to be: the New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 and the HOKA Clifton 9 Two shoes that, while it's true that they have different approaches, can become the perfect pair for your workouts, offering high-end performance at a price that won't make you frown.

Two philosophies, one goal: offer more for less

The New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 and the HOKA Clifton 9 hit the market with different proposals, but with a common denominator: to provide the popular runner with a great running experience at a reasonable price. While the Propel v5 focuses on a mix of reactivity and stability, the Clifton 9 shoe focuses on comfort and cushioning for long distances. Two approaches that, far from competing, can complement each other and offer the runner a versatile and effective pair of running shoes.

New Balance FuelCell Propel v5: versatility within the reach of all budgets.

The fifth version of the New Balance Propel is now a shoe that does not deceive with what it offers. It has a starting price of 130€ (although you know you can compare prices at RUNNEA), and incorporates the FuelCell foam, the most reactive foam line of the American brand. And although we are not going to find the most sophisticated or the fastest foam, you will be able to feel its strength in each stride, offering a sensation that we normally associate with high-end models.

The battle to be the best value for money running shoe New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9 runnea

The breathable mesh upper provides comfort, precise fit and wraps the foot like a glove. The outsole, with NDurance rubber, ensures traction and durability, allowing the shoe to perform on a variety of surfaces, including dirt tracks. And it has a TPU plate (a kind of plastic plate) that serves 2 functions: extra reactivity and greater stability control of the foot strike.

Who is it for?

  • Runners looking for speed, but with support. It's not the fastest shoe, it's not the most stable shoe, but it more than delivers in the 2 areas.
  • Those who enjoy quality workouts, series and lively paces.
  • Medium-weight runners (up to 80 kg) looking for a shoe that is balanced between lightness, performance and support.

HOKA Clifton 9: premium comfort at regular price

The Clifton 9 is HOKA 's answer for those looking for a running shoe with maximum cushioning and comfort without shelling out a fortune for a running shoes. Maintaining the essence of its predecessors, this version has managed to reduce weight and improve the response of the EVA foam midsole.

The battle for the best value running shoe - New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9 runnea

The technical mesh upper offers a secure and adaptable fit, while the Meta geometry facilitates a smooth and efficient transition with every step. All this, without reaching the price points of the brand's other top-of-the-line models.

Who is it for?

  • Runners who prioritize comfort over long distances.
  • Those who want to protect their joints without investing in top-of-the-range shoes.
  • Medium to heavy runners (up to 90 kg) who need generous cushioning.

The perfect synergy: an ideal match for your rotation.

The interesting thing about these two shoes is how they can complement each other in the day-to-day life of the recreational runner. The Propel v5 can be your ally in training at medium or even fast paces, series and short competitions, where you are looking to squeeze the most out of your speed. On the other hand, the Clifton 9 will be your faithful partner on long runs, light runs and recovery days, ensuring that your feet and joints are always protected.

The battle to be the best value running shoe - New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9 runnea

And all this without having to invest in high-end models or specific shoes for each type of training. With this pair, you cover a broad spectrum of needs without breaking the bank.

Running experience: Feel that exceeds expectations

With the New Balance FuelCell Propel v5

From the moment you put them on, you feel that invitation to accelerate. Its lightness is remarkable, and the FuelCell foam along with the TPU plate offers a responsive feel. On fast-paced runs, the shoe shines, allowing you to reach and maintain speeds you might have thought reserved for more expensive models. Even in competitions up to half marathons, the Propel v5 proves competent and reliable. It is, by the way, a shoes that allows you to run close to the asphalt, as its profiles are not too high. Its drop is 6 mm.

The battle to be the best value running shoe - New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 vs HOKA Clifton 9 runnea

With the HOKA Clifton 9

The Hoka Clifton 9 is like that comfortable chair you're looking for when you get home exhausted. Each stride will feel cushioned, reducing impact and allowing you to accumulate kilometers without excessive fatigue. Although it is not the most reactive option for sies or sudden changes of pace, its efficiency in constant rhythms and long distances is undeniable. Ideal for half marathons or even marathons. Also for those days when you simply want to enjoy the camino.

Pros and cons: honesty first and foremost

New Balance FuelCell Propel v5

Pros:

  • Unbeatable price for the performance it offers.
  • Lightweight and responsiveness that rivals more expensive models.
  • Versatility for fast workouts and competitions.

Cons:

  • Fair cushioning for heavier runners over longer distances.
  • Durability may be a factor to consider in intensive use.

HOKA Clifton 9

Pros:

  • Cushioning and comfort worthy of premium models.
  • Durability and quality in materials and construction.
  • Very favorable price-performance ratio in its segment.

Cons:

Less suitable for speed workouts or short series.

Bulky design that may not appeal to everyone.

A smart choice

At the end of the day, what we're looking for is to get the most valor for our money. And in this case, both the Propel v5 and the Clifton 9 offer us more than we might expect for their price. Not only do they deliver, they exceed expectations, positioning themselves as very attractive options in their respective categories.

If your budget is limited but you don't want to compromise on quality and performance, these shoes are a safe bet. And because they can complement each other, they expand your possibilities in training and competition without the need for large investments.

Beyond price, a guaranteed purchase

It's gratifying to find products that prove that the best doesn't always have to be the most expensive. The New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 and the HOKA Clifton 9 are examples that it is possible to enjoy high-end technology and performance without sacrificing our finances.

But beyond numbers and performance, what matters is how they make us feel when we run. If a shoe drives us to excel, to enjoy every mile and to keep our passion for the sport alive, then we have made the right choice.

The search for the best value for money

Not sure which running shoe to choose?

In a few simple steps we help you to choose the ideal running shoe for you

Go to the Shoe Finder

In this battle to be the best value for money shoe, I truly believe there is no loser. Both shoes offer exceptional valor, and the choice will depend on your personal needs and preferences. What is clear is that you don't need to spend a fortune to fit models that allow you to give your best on every ride.

So, if you are looking to renew your equipment without going broke, the New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 and the HOKA Clifton 9 should be on your list of options. You may find that, with them, you're getting a lot more than you pay for. And that, in this day and age, is a victory in itself.

See you out on the pavement, enjoying every stride and knowing you've made a smart choice. Let's run!

Read more news about: Running News

Gorka Cabañas

Gorka Cabañas

Journalist and RUNNEA content director

Director of contents at RUNNEA. Graduate in Information Sciences from the University of the Basque Country. He has worked at El Mundo Deportivo, Grupo Vocento (El Correo) and collaborated for several specialized sports publications.