Hoka Clifton 9, Nike Pegasus 40 and Asics Novablast 4: The battle for the most versatile running shoe

Hoka Clifton 9, Nike Pegasus 40 and Asics Novablast 4: The battle for the most versatile running shoe
Gorka Cabañas
Gorka Cabañas
Journalist and RUNNEA content director
Posted on 29-02-2024

The Hoka Clifton 9, Nike Pegasus 40 and Asics Novablast 4 are currently top of the search rankings on RUNNEA. Why? Because they the most versatile models on the market. That means you have a running shoe that does everything: training, running and racing. But each of these shoes offers distinctive features, designed to meet different needs of each runner. We'll compare these three market-leaders, evaluating key aspects such as comfort, speed, durability and cushioning. Our analysis will focus on the strengths and the weaknesses of each model. And of course, we'll compare prices. So you can decide which shoe is ideal for your running outings.

Not sure which shoe to choose?

In a few simple steps we help you to choose the ideal running shoe for you.

GO TO THE RECOMMENDER

Hoka Clifton 9

Hoka clifton 9

We start with the Hoka Clifton 9: the most visited shoes in RUNNEA in the last few months. Their design is modern and attractive, which is a plus point for runners who are not only looking for performance, but also style. Hoka means pure style.

Performance

The Clifton 9 stands out for their improved cushioning, thanks to a new compression-molded EVA foam formulation that is softer and lighter. This change provides better landing shock dispersion, albeit with moderate energy return. The shoe maintains a considerable sole height (32mm in the heel and 27mm in the toe) with a low 5mm drop, characteristic of Hoka, which favors a quick transition from heel to toe. A shoe with which you can run and work out (although this is not where it performs best).

Comfort and fit

Hoka's focus on comfort is reflected in the upper construction of the Clifton 9, which uses a breathable technical mesh fabric made from recycled materials. The padded tongue and rearfoot area ensure a comfortable fit around the ankles and excellent heel lockdown.

Possible points for improvement

One of the most oft-commented aspects is the toe box, which some runners find too roomy, especially for narrow feet. In terms of pace, it is possibly the slowest shoe of the 3.

The outsole of the Clifton 9 uses Durabrasion technology, with a new design that improves traction on asphalt. Despite its promising performance in durability, on wet tarmac the grip could be improved.

Nike Pegasus 40

Nike Pegasus 40

The Nike Pegasus 40 continues the long tradition of a balance between comfort and performance. With a design that appeals to serious runners and fitness enthusiasts alike, these Nike running shoes are known for versatility over different conditions and distances.

Performance

One of the most notable features of the Pegasus 40 is the responsiveness, thanks to an enhanced cushioning unit that provides an energy boost with every step. It's a top-selling shoe, year after year. And its success lies in its excellent value for money, as well as offering speed and comfort. In addition, the sole technology offers efficient grip, improving safety on a variety of surfaces.

Comfort and fit

The interior of the Pegasus 40 is designed with comfort in mind, with adequate cushioning and arch support, making them suitable for long distances. The upper of the shoe is made with materials that allow for good ventilation, keeping the foot cool and dry. It is not the most comfortable of the 3, but we can consider it a comfortable running shoe. The fit is very good.

Possible points for improvement

The Nike Pegasus needs a major overhaul. It has become a little outdated. It's not something that affects performance, but it's a reality. It is a fast shoe but it lacks cushioning to become even more versatile. That would make it great for both runs and working out.

Asics Novablast 4

Asics Novablast 4

The Asics Novablast 4 have earned a reputation in the running world for outstanding cushioning, reactivity and durability. This model is a popular choice for runners looking for an all-rounder.

Performance and cushioning

The Asics Novablast 4 features FLYTEFOAM Blast cushioning technology, which provides exceptional rebound and boost feel. But at the same time, it brings a soft underfoot feel. It's going to allow you to use them for jogs, leisurely runs, series training and for competitions at any distance.

Durability and design

The Novablast 4 are designed to withstand miles of use without compromising structural integrity or performance. The outsole material and overall build quality contribute to their longevity, making them a worthy investment.

Their modern, racey style has won over the public, too.

Comfort and fit

The upper design of the Novablast 4 emphasises comfort and fit, with materials that offer breathability and proper support. The shoe adapts well to a variety of foot types, making it accessible to a wide range of runners.

Possible points for improvement

Personally, I'd make improvement to the outsole. It lacks some grip. And on wet tarmac, they get slippery.

Final verdict

When comparing the Hoka Clifton 9, Nike Pegasus 40 and Asics Novablast 4, there are clear differences in their design. The Hoka Clifton 9 stands out for comfort, ideal for runners looking for a cozy shoe for long workouts. The Nike Pegasus 40 is positioned the option for those who prioritise speed and response in their training and competitions. Finally, the Asics Novablast 4 stands out for cushioning and durability: the perfect choice for runners who prioritise protection and longevity.

3 interesting alternatives

In addition to these three shoes that are currently leading the market, there are other options that we at RUNNEA consider worthy of attention:

Adidas Supernova Rise: With a combination of support and comfort, these adidas shoes are suitable for runners looking for a balanced shoe for varied workouts.

New Balance Rebel v4: These New Balance running shoes offer a blend of lightness and responsiveness, ideal for runners who enjoy speed and are looking for an agile shoe for fast runs and workouts.

Puma Velocity Nitro 4: With a focus on durability and comfort, these are a solid choice from Puma for runners who value consistency and reliability in their training running shoes.

Read more news about: Running News

Gorka Cabañas

Gorka Cabañas

Journalist and RUNNEA content director

Director of contents at RUNNEA. Graduate in Information Sciences from the University of the Basque Country. He has worked at El Mundo Deportivo, Grupo Vocento (El Correo) and collaborated for several specialized sports publications.